Academic All-Americans
| Athlete | Sport | Year | |
| 1. | Ryan Jorstad | Football | 1960 |
| 2. | Frank Stone | Football | 1975 |
| 3. | Dale Wills | Men's Basketball | 1975 |
| 4. | Roy Mosser | Men's Basketball | 1975 |
| 5. | Jim Dunnan | Football | 1976 |
| 6. | Charlie Sammis | Football | 1976 |
| 7. | Roy Mosser | Men's Basketball | 1976 |
| 8. | Charlie Sammis | Football | 1977 |
| 9. | Roy Mosser | Men's Basketball | 1977 |
| 10. | Dale Wills | Men's Basketball | 1977 |
| 11. | Mark Placey | Football | 1978 |
| 12. | Charlie Sammis | Football | 1978 |
| 13. | Rich Rames | Men's Basketball | 1978 |
| 14. | Gregg Finigan | Men's Basketball | 1978 |
| 15. | Eric Stevens | Football | 1979 |
| 16. | Rich Rames | Men's Basketball | 1979 |
| 17. | Gary Jackson | Men's Basketball | 1979 |
| 18. | Bill Batek | Baseball | 1980 |
| 19. | Gary Jackson | Men's Basketball | 1980 |
| 20. | Karen Colton | Women's Basketball | 1980 |
| 21. | Marianne Larimer | Women's Basketball | 1980 |
| 22. | Gary Jackson | Men's Basketball | 1981 |
| 23. | Karen Colton | Women's Basketball | 1981 |
| 24. | Marty Stupek | Football | 1982 |
| 25. | Marc Knowles | Football | 1983 |
| 26. | Dan Kampwerth | Football | 1983 |
| 27. | Mike Jackson | Men's At-Large (Track) | 1983 |
| 28. | Wayne Dunning | Men's Basketball | 1983 |
| 29. | Tami Sender | Women's Basketball | 1983 |
| 30. | Dan Kampwerth | Football | 1984 |
| 31. | Brian Gifford | Football | 1984 |
| 32. | Cary Bottorf | Football | 1984 |
| 33. | Tom Kreller | Football | 1984 |
| 34. | Greg Collingwood | Men's At-Large (XC/Track) | 1984 |
| 35. | Dan Kampwerth | Football | 1985 |
| 36. | Cary Bottorff | Football | 1985 |
| 37. | Tom Kreller | Football | 1985 |
| 38. | Karla Dittmar | Softball | 1985 |
| 39. | Lori Kerans | Softball | 1985 |
| 40. | Marc Daniels | Baseball | 1987 |
| 41. | Terry Philbin | Football | 1987 |
| 42. | Brian Horst | Men's Basketball | 1987 |
| 43. | Jackie Brown | Volleyball | 1987 |
| 44. | Laura Hutchings | Women's At-Large (Tennis) | 1987 |
| 45. | Jack Klawitter | Baseball | 1988 |
| 46. | Bill Tolone | Baseball | 1988 |
| 47. | Chuck Martin | Football | 1988 |
| 48. | Brian Horst | Men's Basketball | 1988 |
| 49. | Paula Keller | Softball | 1988 |
| 50. | Jack Klawitter | Baseball | 1989 |
| 51. | Chuck Martin | Football | 1989 |
| 52. | Brian Horst | Men's Basketball | 1989 |
| 53. | Denis Fogle | Softball | 1989 |
| 54. | Beth Boston | Softball | 1989 |
| 55. | Tim Eimermann | Football | 1990 |
| 56. | Bob Bergland | Men's At-Large (XC/Track) | 1990 |
| 57. | Karla Kenney | Softball | 1990 |
| 58. | Beth Boston | Softball | 1990 |
| 59. | Denise Fogle | Softball | 1990 |
| 60. | Karla Kenney | Softball | 1991 |
| 61. | Denise Fogle | Softball | 1991 |
| 62. | Jen Ciaccio | Softball | 1992 |
| 63. | Barb Blume-Love | Women's Basketball | 1992 |
| 64. | Laura Tolone | Softball | 1995 |
| 65. | Julie Roe | Women's Basketball (Academic Team Member of the Year) |
1996 |
| 66. | Gwyn Jones | Softball | 1997 |
| 67. | Julie Roe | Women's Basketball | 1997 |
| 68. | Travis Anderson | At-Large (Men's Golf) | 1999 |
| 69. | Andy Beals | Football | 2003 |
| 70. | Lindsay Ippel
|
Women's Basketball (Academic All-America of the Year) |
2008 |