Undefeated Teams
The Millikin University Big Blue has experienced success in every sport offered. During its proud history, 11 teams have recorded perfect seasons while three went through the regular season unbeaten after earning at least one tie with an opponent. Three teams in Millikin history have compiled perfect regular season records before posting its first loss during post-season play.
| Undefeated Teams In Millikin History | Coach |
| 1919 Football (9-0) | Norman J. Wann |
| 1920 Football (9-0) | Norman J. Wann |
| 1941 Football (8-0) | Marshall Wells |
| 1942 Football (7-0) | C.E. Sutherd |
| 1946 Baseball (11-0) | Don Lindeberg |
| 1959-60 Wrestling (4-0) | Charles Ross |
| 1961 Football (8-0)* | Don Shroyer |
| 1981-82 Men’s Swimming (4-0) | Tony Young |
| 1985-86 Men’s Swimming (8-0) | Tony Young |
| 1985-86 Women’s Swimming (7-0) | Tony Young |
| 1986-87 Men’s Swimming (13-0)* | Tony Young |
| 1987-88 Men’s Swimming (12-0)* | Tony Young |
| Unbeaten Teams in Millikin History | Coach |
| 1916 Football (8-0-1) | Norman J. Wann |
| 1928 Football (6-0-2) | Leo T. Johnson |
| 1934 Football (7-0-1) | Leo T. Johnson |
| Only Loss Came During Post-Season Play | Coach |
| 1919 Men’s Basketball (23-1) | Robert Brannan |
| 1989 Football (10-1)* | Carl Poelker |
| 1997-98 Women’s Basketball (25-1)* | Lori Kerans |
* - team won a College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) Championship
(CCIW competition began in 1946-47 for men and 1985-86 for women)